For those of you who are like me and want to experience the joy of actually discovering the eggs in MLB The Show 25—Cheap mlb 25 stubsnot just reading a list and checking boxes—this post is for you.

Here are some spoiler-free tips to help you uncover each egg naturally while still enjoying the mystery:

Pay Attention to Clues in Titles and Dialog

The names of each egg have puns or hidden meanings. Think like a baseball player—what does “Three Bags Full” mean? What would “Sunny Side Up” hint at?

Experiment Across Game Modes

You’ll need to play Ranked, Events, Conquest, BR, and Mini Seasons. If you’ve only been grinding one or two, you’re missing triggers.

Use the Egg Hunt Cards in Lineups

Some eggs or bonus objectives seem to require players you unlocked from earlier eggs. Equip those cards, even if they’re bench guys.

Watch for In-Game Messages or Animations

Occasionally, completing an egg won’t show until after you leave the game and go to the main Program screen. Be patient—it might be there.

Check the Exchange Tab

One egg is triggered by trading in items, but you won’t know what until you explore. Gather items from Moments, Conquest, and gameplay drops.

Keep a Notepad or Checklist

Track what you’ve tried and what you haven’t. That way, you don’t waste time repeating a task you already completed.

I finished nine of the ten eggs before even looking up clues. It felt way more satisfying solving each one based on baseball logic, in-game text, and just messing around. Highly recommend trying it this way before peeking at a guide.

Anyone else going the spoiler-free route? Would love to hear how far you got before getting stumped.